BLOGGER TEMPLATES - TWITTER BACKGROUNDS

Sunday, June 10, 2007

CRUEL BUT REAL.....

It’s been three days I last updated my blog….while enjoying my weekend with my kids , I also spent some time searching on a popular topic which has long been swirling in my mind…how can it happen?…is it real ?.... almost all WH questions that I have in mind …I got almost all the answers on this cruel but real crime………..HONOUR KILLING….

HONOUR KILLING…… this is what I got from a few websites on this topic ....

An honour killing is a murder, nearly exclusively of a woman, who has been perceived as having brought dishonour to her family. Such killings are typically perpetrated by the victim's own relatives and/or community and unlike crimes of passion or rage-induced killings, usually planned in advance.

In societies and cultures where they occur, such killings are often regarded as a "private matter" for the affected family alone, and courts rarely become involved or prosecute the perpetrators.




A POEM BY MAHA ABU AYYASH

They are killed, and any memory of their "dishonored" existence is deliberately erased.
Do they have gravestones and epitaphs?
You cannot hear the weeping of their mothers.
There are no condolences, no questions nor answers.
They suffer brutal violence - are killed without reason: it is injustice.
The sentence against them is brutal - a punishment for crimes not committed, handed down without evidence, witnesses, judges or trials.
As a society we endorse the verdict after it is rendered.
Mercy is not a factor weighed on the tilted scales of justice used to judge them.
Their lives vanish into the hell of the forgotten.
We fail to protect them, and their lives are gone in vain.


The report concerning cultural practices in the family that are violent towards women, indicated that honour killings had been reported in Egypt, Iran, Jordan, Lebanon, Morocco, the Syrian Arab Republic, Turkey, Yemen, and other Mediterranean and Gulf countries, and that they had also taken place in such countries as France, Germany and the United Kingdom within migrant communities.

Here in Jordan , in a desert nation of conservative Bedouin tribes, activists are trying to scrap the time-honored law that gives men light sentences for murdering female relatives for offenses to family honour. It took Ahmad Ismail two months to track down his teen-age sister Haneen who had fled home with a boyfriend .

When Ahmad pulled the trigger, 19-year-old Haneen was two months pregnant. Ahmad, now 17, spent one year in jail and then was released to a hero's welcome from his family and neighbours.

"I cleansed our family honour," he said at his family home in the dirt alleyways of this town, 17 miles northeast of the Jordanian capital, Amman.

"She disgraced us," he said. "We are a tribe of thousands of men. It was better that one person die, but not the thousands, of shame."

Ahmad's thankful father, Mahmoud, concurred: "Our neighbors and even relatives had stopped talking to us until Ahmad carried out his heroic act."

"Now, we can walk with our heads held high," he added.

In Jordan, One-Quarter of All Murders Are 'For Honour'

Haneen was one of scores of Jordanian women who face, or faced, family retribution in this conservative, tribal-oriented society where men rule on family matters and women, who constitute 49 percent of the 4.6 million population, have little say.

Official statistics show that 25 women--the majority of them teen-agers--are killed each year in so-called "honor crimes," which constitute 25 percent of the annual homicides in Jordan. Most are buried in unmarked graves, disgraced even in death.


Honor killing is forbidden in mainstream interpretations of Islam
Many Muslim scholars and commentators say that honor killings are a cultural practice which is neither exclusive to, nor universal within, the Islamic world.

Many campaigns to stop this 'cruel but real ' crime are being carried out all over the Middle East..... I personally really hope this crime will no longer exist in this enchanting Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, InsyaAllah.

17 comments:

Daphne Ling said...

Hi LUJ,

Wanted to pop here a long time ago, but...Oh well...

That was a great, thought-provoking post...

Unfortunately, honour killing is something which is very very exceptable in many societies...It's a tradition that has been going on for years, and generations...

Laws aren't really going to help, because then these killings and murders will just take place quietly and everything will be hushed up...

What we need is, yes very cliche, education...They need to realise that honour-killing is not ok, and no, society is not trying to patronise their views on them...

I mean, how can anyone pull a trigger on their on flesh-and-blood? Just because she got pregnant? You're taking two lives...And of course, no one says anything about the guy who impregnated her...She couldn't have done it alone, could she?

Because if she could, I'm interested in hearing how...

Come to think of it, how could anyone just pull a trigger, flesh-and-blood, or otherwise?

And come back to a hero's welcome?

Well (yes, I know I sound very condescending), I'll be damned...

zino said...

dah ada bunga kluar hehe

Sya said...

wah lamo den tak masuk rupo ei dah tukar muko baghu ... cantik laei.,. sojuk mato den mandang. Den tak nak komen tang posting nuu tak roti den.

J.T. said...

Very insightful piece you have here. This is one of the topics that get me riled up (including anything else that pertains to abusing women).

No amount of laws are going to stop those imbeciles from acting the way they want. To be welcomed back as heroes after 'saving the family's name' is downright deplorable. As Daphne said, the girl does not get pregnant on her own.. the man had something to do with it.

It is true that such things are happening in Europe in migrant communities. I've heard of it and it is very, very unfortunate that these people bring their archaic practices along with them.

Education is important but it won't happen overnight. It will take a generation or two to be rid of such selfish-thinking. That too.. if they want to be educated on that.

silversarina said...

Daphne Ling,

Thanks for dropping by....

It's really hard to say when it involves the family honour, the arabs are known for their close-knit family ties ( each clan with its own pride ), most of them are educated citizens and there was a case involving a college student who was shot dead by her own biological father and the boyfriend was killed by his own clan for the sake of clan /tribe honour... Hopefully with majority of the jordanians are highly educated , this crime will come to a stop... it's very difficult to really understand their culture and norms..


+++++++++++


zino,


ohh cursor bunga tu, my 'secretary' buatkan....

silversarina said...

sya,

ha ah den ni asyik 'renovate' rumah ajo, cantik ko tak cantik ko, den tak kisah do... lamo den tak nampak sya kek rumah den ni ha....

den bukan apo, heran orang arab ni main bunuh keluargo sobab nak jago maruah...ontahlah den pun tak faham budayo arab kek sini...

jomputlah datanglah laiii :)


+++++++++++


j.t. ,


You're right. Education is the tool but do they really want the education that involves 'cutting off' their long traditional norm and culture ?

When this crime happens, the authority has nothing to say, the tribe is the boss, they just have to clean their tribe's name and honour.... maybe if I live in their tribe for my whole life , then only I would be able to understand their mind and culture...if and only if...

J.T. said...

Exactly Sarinah. We do not live in their tribes and so we do not understand where they come from.

Still, what honour is there when one kills a family member? As the poster says "there is no honour in killing". Have we ever heard of them killing a man for shaming the family? He gets off scot-free sometimes. A 65-year old man can rape a 13-year old girl and that's a light crime or sometimes no crime at all. All they are interested in safeguarding is the man's libido. The women rarely have any rights. This is just not in the middle east. The African countries and some Asian countries have the same problem.

Back to education and if they want to make that change. If tribes keep going with what they believe in, it will never change no matter how many generations pass.

Thanks for giving me so much space to voice what I feel. :)

silversarina said...

j.t.,

Now many NGOs are trying their best to stop this crime and demand the killers being arrested and put in jail/sentence to death ... of course it will take ages to make it a reality..till then many more women would be the victims :(

Thanks for sharing your thoughts..

J.T. said...

Glad that NGOs are trying their best to stop the crime. There is hope yet. :) A little effort is better than nothing, right?

Pi Bani said...

When something has become a tradition or culture, it's very very difficult to change. Just like the Malays' "biar mati anak, jangan mati adat" mentality.

NGOs may be trying their best, but when it comes to upholding the law, the authorities will have to play a bigger role. I mean... just ONE year in jail for killing own sister??!

lelakhalidah said...

ya.. insightful piece of entry.. I hv read once honor killing.. & hope they could stop this!

Makcik Runner said...

this sort of crime kedengaran masih rampant kat negeri2 belah arab mcm jordan even pakistan pun ada dengar this type of senseless killing. ada satu kes kat pakistan kalo x silap) family members consist of womenfolks boleh kena rape cenggitu je kalo another clan nak balas dendam and its permissible...goodness!

silversarina said...

j.t. ,

Let's hope for the best !



++++++++++


Pi bani,


Bila bab maruah family, polis tak masuk cmpur, hukuman pun al kadar je.


++++++++++++++


lelakhalidah,


Dulu ingat macam dibuat je cerita ni, but it is still happening :(


+++++++++++++


kc,


Macam-macam adat yang masih dipertahankan walaupun melibatkan jenayah kejam .... kita amat bersyukur adat ini tiada dalam tradisi kita..

blackpurple @ jowopinter said...

Siapa agaknya patut dipersalahkan?

Puisi maha abu ayyash itu tepat menceritakan realitinya!

silversarina said...

blackpurple,

Kalau akak , akak persalahkan tradisi yang ditaati membabi buta... time and the world have changed.... budaya boleh diubah hendak lagi ianya bertentangan dengan ikutan agama.... It's manusia yang meletakkan ianya satu yang 'halal' dan manusia jugalah yang semestinya mengubah itu semua...

Anonymous said...

These people need to re-study the Quran. They call themselves Muslims, and yet they think it's ok to carry out such a big sin. Very confusing to non-Muslims.

silversarina said...

hazia,

Bila cakap pasal ISLAM berdegar-degar, bila bab praktis, adat diutamakan...diaorang yang sebabkan islam dihina.